Fox has finally come into it’s own. They have produced a line up of shows that seem to be performing well in the ratings category. The combination of laid back and light comedy, mixed with the dark and gritty drama’s seem to be spelling success for the studio. Gotham is possibly one of the biggest hits that fox has in its current rotation. Gotham is a spin off of the Popular Batman comic that has been around since 1939, and is one of the feature hero’s from DC Comics. Gotham takes place right after Bruce Wayne’s parents are gunned down in the streets. The Show follows A Young James Gordon, a detective as well as an even younger Bruce Wayne.
While the show will jump around to a multitude of various characters, including Selina Kyle (Cat), Oswalt Cobblepot (Penguin), and Bruce Wayne; the show mainly follows James Gordon. Detective Gordon moves so the city of Gotham and finds himself in a city over run by corruption. He makes it her personal job to find Wayne’s killer and clean up the corruption that has infected the city of Gotham like a plague. Detective Gordon constantly finds himself caught between the justice that he seeks, and the seedy underbelly that grips the city, making him go along with the corruption to allow him to continue his mission of finding the Wayne’s Killer.
Now i don’t consider myself an expert on Batman, but i am a huge fan of the comic, the shows, and the cartoons that have followed. The movies have been hit and miss. I was a fan of the Dark Knight series, more so than the earlier versions of the batman movie franchise. While i find the new look at the batman franchise refreshing, i have some reservations about the show. I am not saying that i hate the new show and think that it is ruining the batman franchise, there are a few things that bug me and take away from what is a really good show.
Good-Story
The Show in general does have a very dark and gritty feel, which i really do enjoy. There is quite a good bit of suspense that goes on which will keep the viewer quite interested in the episode. They do a pretty good job of keeping things relatively real world where the comics and a few of the movies have tended to stray off into the fantasy realm. I like how detective Gordon seems to really toe the line between good and evil. He is generally a good character, he tries to be the one shining light in Gotham where inch is covered in the filth of corruption. He occasionally finds himself having to play by the thugs rules and act as he must for the greater good and to reach his ultimate goal of finding the man who killed the Wayne’s.
Bad-Technology/Time Period
One of the most confusing parts of the television show, is the exact time period that this show is taking place in. It has a very 1950’s feel, with cars and the dress. Most of the men are in suits and the women in dresses. In the Pilot episode, they are in a diner and there is a woman wearing a 50’s style waitress outfit. You can quite often catch older model cars that look brand new. Some how in Gotham, their are color television and cellphones but yet there is not a computer to be found on any desk. I realize that i may be picking at hairs, it is just a little confusing that there are television’s and cellphones combined with older style dress and vehicles, yet computers were left out. The City is almost a modern day gothic style city, where it moved on with certain technologies but is still trapped in a 50’s area feeling.
Good- Penguin, Alfred, Selina Kyle.
there are some very good characters that are in this show, that really make the story. While there are others who are lack luster in their story line.
Oswald “Penguin” Cobblepot.
He is quite possibly one of the best characters in the show. The movies did no justice to the Penguin. He was portrayed as a bungling idiot of a criminal. The original Penguin was short and chubby with a big nose. Even though he came from a wealthy family just like Bruce, he was never accepted and was constantly picked on. The Gotham Version is skinny and has a very sinister side to him. He does not come from wealth like his comic counter part but i think that really makes him ever better. He acts like he is an easy to push around servant, but as you watch the show you can tell that he is playing everyone. He is quite diabolical. His ability to manipulate and control people is what makes him an amazing villain.
Alfred.
Now when most people think about Alfred the butler they think of a simple easy going butler that helps batman with the day to day and assists him when he is pretending to be a millionaire playboy. There is another version of Alfred out there where Alfred was a Former MI6 agent who became a butler for the Wayne family. The later version is the Alfred in the series of Gotham, which i prefer over the quite plain butler. He has a very grizzled voice and demeanor. He will lash out at Bruce when he makes a mistake but he will quickly apologize and show how much he cares for Bruce.
Selina Kyle.
Now i have to say when i first saw Selina Kyle, i honestly thought she was in her twenty’s. She just has a mature look to her. Someone i talked to had told me that she was in her twenties, but after looking her up on google, it turns out she is 15. That is good, knowing that makes it a little easier, but she still has a look that she is a bit older than Bruce, who is played by a 13 yr old. At first i was not a fan of Cat, but now i must say i do like her. Granted the Original Selina Kyle back story would not work.(( Her original character who was an adult was a Dominatrix in the comics.)) Her being a quick thinking street urchin really fits the Cat burglar style persona she takes on later in life.
Bad Ivy Pepper.
I just want to make a quick point, that you briefly run into Ivy Pepper, who i assume will eventually become poison Ivy. The thing that bothers me is in Gotham her parents are poor. In the Comics, her parents were wealthy but distant, leading to her paranoid and obsessive behavior. Also her name in the Comics is Pamela Isley. I don’t understand why they changed her name and her background, and it irritates me slightly.
Bad. The almost endless corruption.
Now I realize that Gotham was always a rather corrupt city, even in the comics. There is a seemingly endless supply of criminals and villains flooding the streets, but in the television show is seems a little ridiculous. There are two major Crime families and a seemingly endless supply of under bosses that want to take out their boss. The entire police force has been bought by the crime syndicates except for Detective Gordon, and the two people from major crimes. Harvey Bullock starts off as a pretty dirty cop, who changes his ways because of Gordon. I just can’t see that the entire police force being on the take with the crime family. the cops are either completely inept or incredibly dirty. There should be a few good cops somewhere in Gotham.
I realize that people will scream at me that the original Gotham was incredibly corrupt before batman showed up, but it just seems a little over kill in the context of the show. My gripes with the show are very small and probably something your average viewer won’t notice nor care but i just wish that there was a little more cohesion within the show. I just find it a little weird there are cellphones and modern technology (ex phone activated car bombs.) and yet there are somehow no computers and everyone seems to be from the 50’s era. This won’t stop me from watching the show but i just hope that season two will clean up a bit of the stray hairs that seem to be poking out. Maybe i am just picking at hairs, but it is just small things i have noticed.